Anthropological Critique and the Karamoja Question: Reflections on the Post Disarmament Livelihood Sources and Gender Disparities in the North East Region of Uganda
Abstract
It is presumed that the Karamoja question is due to an anthropological lack of post-disarmament development strategies. This specifically applies to the mismanagement of gender relations. The paper concludes that the Karamoja Question persists because the post-disarmament development organisations prioritise women as change agents. This approach created gender disparities that resulted in a masculinities crisis. Consequently, gender as a social structure became dysfunctional and women have ended up being overwhelmed with both productive and reproductive roles while men are grappling with alcohol, violence, and social lethargy. These conditions cannot enable sustainable development. Anthropologically, gender is a vibrant social structure that determines the system of community governance and management of resources. Therefore, development interventions ought to analyse and incorporate accepted gender relations if they are to succeed in their programs. To resolve the Karamoja question, it is recommended that development agencies integrate social norms to enable hybrid approaches that are socially acceptable. This is because all matters of the Karamojong lifestyle revolve around participation and respect through dialogue and consensus
Downloads
References
The Uganda Bureau of Statistics in 2019 reported that Karamoja suffers the highest poverty rate of 60.2 percent, way above Uganda's national average of 21.4 percent.
Republic of Uganda, The Third Karamoja Integrated Development Plan, 2021/22 – 2025/26 (Kampala: Office of Prime Minister, 2021),4.
Novelli Bruno, Aspects of Karamojong EthnoSociology (Verona: Museum-Combonianum, 1988), 81.
Carrie S. Huisman “Once Patriarchs and Worriers: Masculinity and Modernity in Karamoja, Uganda” Praxis The Fletcher Journal of Human Security Volume XXVI (2011):60-80, 65.
Republic of Uganda, Karamoja Integrated Disarmament and Development Programme: “Creating Conditions for Promoting Human Security and Recovery in Karamoja, 2007/2008-2009/2010” (Kampala: Office of Prime Minister, 2007),5-12.
Republic of Uganda, The Third Karamoja Integrated Development Plan, 2021/22 – 2025/26 (Kampala: Office of Prime Minister, 2021),11.
Bruno Novelli, Aspects of Karamojong EthnoSociology (Verona: Museum-Combonianum, 1988), 85 & 87.
Carrie S. Huisman “Once Patriarchs and Worriers: Masculinity and Modernity in Karamoja, Uganda” Praxi s The Fletcher Journal of Human Security Volume XXVI (2011):60-80, 66.
Novelli Bruno, Aspects of Karamojong EthnoSociology (Verona: Museum-Combonianum, 1988),93-101.
Elizabeth Stites and Darlington Akabwai “We Are Now Reduced to Women’: Impacts of Forced Disarmament in Karamoja, Uganda Nomadic Peoples” (2010) Volume 14, Issue 2,
(2010): 24–43.
Carrie S. Huisman “Once Patriarchs and Worriers: Masculinity and Modernity in Karamoja, Uganda” Praxis the Fletcher Journal of Human Security Volume XXVI (2011):60-80.
John Ssenkaaba (2015) The Changing Livelihood of the Karamojong People of North-Eastern Uganda and its impact on the Survival of their Traditional Gender Roles (UiT-The Arctic: Centre for Sami Studies, UiT-The Arctic University of Norway, 2015), p?
Sheena Crawford and Margaret Kasiko, Support for Strategic Review and Planning to Strengthen Dfid’s Work on Gender Equality and Women and Girls Empowerment in Karamoja Region, Uganda (London: Coffey International Development Ltd, 2016),64.
Sheena Crawford and Margaret Kasiko, Support for Strategic Review and Planning to Strengthen Dfid’s Work on Gender Equality and Women and Girls Empowerment in Karamoja Region, Uganda (London: Coffey International Development Ltd, 2016),64.
Sheena Crawford and Margaret Kasiko, Support for Strategic Review and Planning To Strengthen DFID’s Work On Gender Equality And Women And Girls Empowerment In Karamoja Region, Uganda (London: Coffey International Development Ltd, 2016), p.2.
Elizabeth Stites and Darlington Akabwai “We Are Now Reduced to Women’: Impacts of Forced Disarmament In Karamoja, Uganda Nomadic Peoples” (2010) Volume 14, Issue 2, (2010): 24–43.
John Ssenkaaba (2015) The Changing Livelihood of the Karamojong People of North-Eastern Uganda and its impact on the Survival of their Traditional Gender Roles (UiT-The Arctic: Centre for Sami Studies, UiT-The Arctic University of Norway, 2015), 38-39.
Kennedy A. Mkutu (2008) “Uganda: Pastoral Conflict & Gender Relations” Review of African Political Economy, no.35:116, (2008), 242.
Aylward Shorter, African Culture: An Overview (Nairobi: Pauline Publication Africa, 2001)10.
Robert Edwards Lenkeit, Introducing Cultural Anthropology (New York: MC Graw Hill 2004), 4.
Bodley, John H. "Anthropology." Microsoft® Student 2009 [DVD]. Redmond, WA: Microsoft Corporation, 2008.
Sheena Crawford and Margaret Kasiko, Support for Strategic Review and Planning to Strengthen Dfid’s Work on Gender Equality and Women and Girls Empowerment In Karamoja Region, Uganda (London: Coffey International Development Ltd, 2016),3.
Maria Eriksson Baaz, The paternalism of Partnership: A Post colonial Reading of Identity in Development Aid. (London: Zed Books LTD 2005).
Maria Eriksson Baaz, The paternalism of Partnership: A Post colonial Reading of Identity in Development Aid. (London: Zed Books LTD 2005), 56.
United Nations Development Programme, Uganda Human Development Report 2015, Unlocking the Development Potential of Northern Uganda. (New York: UNDP: 2015), 40.
United Nations Development Programme, Uganda Human Development Report 2015, Unlocking the Development Potential of Northern Uganda. (New York: UNDP: 2015), 40-41.
Oyeronke Oyewumi, The Invention of Women: Making an African Sense of Western Gender Discourses (Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 1997), 37.
Oyeronke Oyewumi, The Invention of Women: Making an African Sense of Western Gender Discourses (Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press, 1997), 35.
Raewyn Connell, Short introduction to Gender (Cambridge: polity press, 2009), 11.
Alexander Kagaha, Jacqueline Mugisha, and Sylvia Atugonza, Livelihoods, Culture and Gender: A Situational Analysis of the Challenges and Opportunities for addressing Gender-Based Violence in Karamoja Region, (Pokot Zonal Integrated Development Programme (POZIDEP): Karamoja Dioceses Development Services, 2009).
Kisiangani, E.N Waswa, “Decolonising Gender Studies in Africa” Gender Scholarship: Concepts, Methodologies and Paradigms (2004): 9-26, 8.
Baron Oron and Alice Welbourn, “Interpersonal neurobiology and the prevention of gender-based violence” Mangesh Kulkarni, Rimjhim Jain Eds. Global Masculinities. Interrogating and Reconstructions, (New York: Routledge 2018), 99-115, 66.
John Ssenkaaba (2015) The Changing Livelihood of the Karamojong People of North-Eastern Uganda and its impact on the Survival of their Traditional Gender Roles (UiT-The Arctic: Centre for Sami Studies, UiT-The Arctic University of Norway, 2015), 38-39.
Mercy Amba Oduyoye, Daughters of Anowa. (MaryKnoll: Orbis Books 1995),11.
Musa Dube, Postcolonial Feminist Interpretation of the Bible, (St. Louis Missouri: Charice Press, 2000).
Saferworld, “Peace, Security and Justice in Karamoja: Amplifying the voices of women and girls” Briefing (Kampala: 2020).
Africa Borderland Centre, The Karamoja Cluster Rapid Conflict Analysis and Gender Assessment in Kenya and Uganda, (New York: UNDP, 2022), 4.
United Nations Development Programme, Uganda Human Development Report 2015, Unlocking the Development Potential of Northern Uganda. (New York: UNDP: 2015), 62 &69.
Sheena Crawford and Margaret Kasiko, Support for Strategic Review and Planning to Strengthen Dfid’s Work on Gender Equality and Women and Girls Empowerment In Karamoja Region, Uganda (London: Coffey International Development Ltd, 2016),3.
Novelli Bruno, Aspects of Karamojong EthnoSociology (Verona: Museum-Combonianum, 1988),42-44.
Khristopher Carlson, Keith Proctor, Elizabeth Stites, and Darlington Akabwai , Tradition in Transition: Customary Authority in Karamoja, Uganda. (Feinstein International Center: Tufts University, 2012),8-19.
Paul Crawshaw, Alex Scott-Samuel, and Stanistreet Debbi. 'Masculinities, hegemony, and structural violence', Criminal Justice Matters, 81 (1), (2010),2-4, 2.
Kennedy A. Mkutu (2008) “Uganda: Pastoral Conflict & Gender Relations” Review of African Political Economy, no.35:116, (2008), 242.
Mercy Amba Oduyoye, Daughters of Anowa. (MaryKnoll: Orbis Books 1995),11.
Paul Crawshaw, Alex Scott-Samuel and Debbi. (2010) 'Masculinities, hegemony,
and structural violence', Criminal Justice Matters, 81 (1), pp.2-4.
Paul Crawshaw, Alex Scott-Samuel, and Stanistreet Debbi (2010) 'Masculinities, hegemony, and structural violence', Criminal Justice Matters, 81 (1), pp.2-4,3.
Ben Knighton, “Belief in guns and warlords: freeing Karamojong identity from Africanist theory” African Identities, 4:2, (2006) 269-286.
Liz Stones and Laurie Bell, Skills, Income and Livelihoods in Karamoja Programme (SILK), (Concern Worldwide, 2017), 27 & 36.
Tim Carrigan, Bob Connell and John Lee., “HARD AND HEAVY. Toward a New Sociology of Masculinity” Whitehead. S., Ed. Men and Masculinities: Critical concepts in Sociology, (London: Routledge, 2006), 306 – 331.
Elizabeth Stites, Anastasia Marshak, Emily Nohner, Simon Richards, and Darlington Akabwai (2014) Engaging Male Youth in Karamoja, Uganda. An Examination of The Factors Driving the Perpetration of Violence and Crime by Young Men in Karamoja and the Applicability of a Communications and Relationships Program to Address Related Behavior, (Washington DC: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank, 2014),4-5.
Elizabeth Stites, Anastasia Marshak, Emily Nohner, Simon Richards, and Darlington Akabwai (2014) Engaging Male Youth in Karamoja, Uganda. An Examination of The Factors Driving the Perpetration of Violence and Crime by Young Men in Karamoja and the Applicability of a Communications and Relationships Program to Address Related Behavior, (Washington DC: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank, 2014),4-5.
Sheena Crawford and Margaret Kasiko, Support for Strategic Review and Planning to Strengthen DFID’s Work on Gender Equality and Women and Girls Empowerment in Karamoja Region, Uganda (London: Coffey International Development Ltd 2016), 34.
Elizabeth Stites, Anastasia Marshak, Emily Nohner, Simon Richards, and Darlington Akabwai (2014) Engaging Male Youth in Karamoja, Uganda. An Examination of The Factors Driving the Perpetration of Violence and Crime by Young Men in Karamoja and the Applicability of a Communications and Relationships Program to Address Related Behavior, (Washington DC: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank, 2014),5-6.
Maria Eriksson Baaz, The paternalism of Partnership: A Post colonial Reading of Identity in Development Aid. (London: Zed Books LTD 2005), 56.
Novelli Bruno, Aspects of Karamojong EthnoSociology (Verona: Museum-Combonianum, 1988),18.
Augusto Pazzaglia, The Karamojong: Some Aspects (Bologna: Museum Combonianum, 1982),98.
Reginald A. Radcliffe-Brown, A. Structure and Function in Primitive Society: Essays and Addresses. Oxford: Free press 1965.
Thomas Bartfield, The Dictionary of Anthropology. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1997.
William Desmond, Being and the Between. New York: Routetege 1995.
Aloysius Lugira, African Religion: World Religions. New York: Facts On File, Inc 2004.
Victor Turner, The Forest of Symbols: Aspects of Ndembu Ritual. London: Cornell 1967. University Press.
Victor Turner, The Drums of Affliction. London: International African Institute 1986.
Victor Turner, The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. Chicago: Aldine Publishing Company 1969.
Walter Goldschmidt, Sebei Law Berkeley: University of California Press 1967.
Walter Goldschmidt, Culture and Behaviour of the Sebei: A Study in Continuity and Adaptation. London: University of California Press 1976.
Maulana Karenga, Kawaida: A Communitarian African Philosophy. Los Angeles: University of Sankore 1997.
Maulana Karenga, Kwanzaa: A celebration of Family, Community and Culture. Los Angeles: University of Sankore Press 1998.
Laurent Magesa, African Religion: The Moral Traditions of Abundant Life. Nairobi: Paulines Publications Africa 1998.
Some Malidoma, The Healing Wisdom of Africa: Finding Life Purpose through Nature, Ritual and Community. New York: Jeremy P. Tarcher/Pautnam 1998.
Novelli Bruno, Aspects of Karamojong EthnoSociology (Verona: Museum-Combonianum, 1988), 63-72.
Novelli Bruno, Aspects of Karamojong EthnoSociology (Verona: Museum-Combonianum, 1988), 44-49
Pazzaglia, Augusto. The Karamojong: Some Aspects. Bologna: Museum Combonianum, 1982.
Thomas Bartfield, The Dictionary of Anthropology, (Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1997),410-411.
David B. Brinkerhoff, Lynn White, The Essentials of Sociology, (New York: West Publishing Company 1989), 45.
Government of Uganda, Kampala: Ministry of Gender, Labour and Community Development, 2024). Refer to the links of: https://mglsd.go.ug/ [https://mglsd.go.ug/uwep/ https://mglsd.go.ug/ylp/, https://mglsd.go.ug/esp/]
Maria Eriksson Baaz, “African Identity and The Post-Colonial” Mai Palmberg and Maria Eriksson Baaz (Eds) Same and Other: Negotiating African Identity in Cultural Production (Uppsala: Nordiska Afrikainstitutet, 2001), 5-21.
Sandra Gray, “A Memory of Loss: Ecological Politics, Local History, and the Evolution of Karimojong Violence”. Human Organization, (2000): 401-418, 401.
Maria Eriksson Baaz, “African Identity and The Post-Colonial” Mai Palmberg and Maria Eriksson Baaz (Eds) Same and Other: Negotiating African Identity in Cultural Production (Uppsala: Nordiska Afrikainstitutet, 2001).
Government of Uganda, Karamoja Investment Profile 2016, (Kampala: Uganda Investment Authority, 2016).5.
Victoria Brown, Marion Kelly and Travor Mabugu, The Education System in Karamoja. (Oxford: HEART, a consortium of: Oxford Policy Management, 2017),12-13.
Victoria Brown, Marion Kelly and Travor Mabugu, The Education System in Karamoja. (Oxford: HEART, a consortium of: Oxford Policy Management,2017),12-13.
Onyango Otieno. African Masculinity, Trauma, and Healing. Posted on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vhCg9562E5k [ accessed on 27/4/2024].
Novelli Bruno, Aspects of Karamojong EthnoSociology (Verona: Museum-Combonianum, 1988), 111-113.
Government of public of Uganda, The Third Karamoja Integrated Development Plan, 2021/22 – 2025/26 (Kampala: Office of Prime Minister, 2021), 4.
Copyright (c) 2024 Tabitha Naisiko
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
