South Sudan: Marital Rape Exemption

  • Nyuol Justin Yaac Arop The South Sudan Human Rights Commission
Sambaza Makala:

Ikisiri

This paper explores marital rape in South Sudan by delving into the complex history of customary law in South Sudan and how it came about, as well as the precarious legal position that victims of marital rape find themselves in. The research maintains that the marital exemption clause in the laws of South Sudan should be abolished and, in its place, a law that penalizes rape within the institution of marriage should be enacted. The paper makes a significant contribution to the literature because the topic explored is relevant to the discussion of marital rape, not only in South Sudan, but also in other countries where similar problems persist. The paper does so by critically engaging with the issue of marital rape in South Sudan, explores its history, and proposes that changes must be made not only to the way in which the crime is defined but also how its punished.  In conclusion the paper implores South Sudan’s decision makers to forge ways to criminalize marital rape but stops short of expressing with precision how the new changes should look like or how it should be done. Purposefully, the paper interrogates whether the validity of this archaic law is sustained by cultural imperative. Methodically, it does so by qualitatively analysing South Sudan’s statutory laws, traditional beliefs and cultures. The research findings conclude that while traditional cultures may have contributed to the repugnancy, its sustenance is the result of complex interplay between political and economic interests central to the governing elites. Finally, the paper maintains that times have changed dramatically and these interests, once viewed as necessary to ensure stability and perpetual governance, have long lost that value, and arguably, are detrimental to a democratic, inclusive state

Upakuaji

Bado hatuna takwimu za upakuaji.

Marejeleo

Sally Engle Merry, ‘Legal Pluralism’ The Globalization of International Law (Routledge 2017) 29.

Code of Civil Procedure Act 2007 (South Sudan) S. 6(a).

Constitution of South Sudan Article 15.

Ibid, 3 Art. 15(2).

Ibid, 3.

In this paper, marital rape, marital exemption, spousal exemption, and spousal immunity are all used interchangeably.

Jan Arno Hessbruegge, ‘Customary Law and Authority in a State under Construction: The Case of South Sudan’ (2012) 5(3) African Journal of Legal Studies 295.

The partition resulted in the creation of two states: the Republic of South Sudan and the Republic of Sudan.

R.S O’Fahey, ‘Islam and Ethnicity in the Sudan’ (1996) 26(3) Journal of Religion in Africa 258.

Liv Tonnessen, ‘Women at Work in Sudan: Marital Privilege or Constitutional Right?’ (2019) 26(2) Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State & Society 223.

Elias Nyamlell Wakoson, ‘Sudan’s Addis Ababa Peace Treaty: Why it Failed’ (1990) 12(2/3) Northeast African Studies 19.

Bona Malwal, ‘The Anya-Nya Liberation Movement, 1955-1974. Sudan and South Sudan: From One to Two’ (Springer 2015) 66-85.

Kuol Deng-Abot Kuol, ‘An Investigation into the Roles of Traditional Leadership in the Liberation Struggle in Southern Sudan 1983-2005’ Master’s Degree Dissertation Thesis (2008) University of Fort Hare, accessed on 13 May 2014 via, https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/145052338.pdf

Douglas H. Johnson, ‘The Political Crisis in South Sudan’ (2014) 57(3) African Studies Review 167.

Kevin L. Cope, ‘South Sudan’s Dualistic Constitution,’ in Denis J. Galligan and Mila Versteeg (eds), Social and Political Foundations of Constitutions (Cambridge University Press 2013) 295.

The Penal Code Act 2008 (Republic of South Sudan) Section 247(1)

Penal Code of South Sudan Section 247(3)

Hilkje Charlotte Hanel, ‘What is Rape? Social Theory and Conceptual Analysis’ viewed on 1 May 2024 on https://www.ssoar.info/ssoar/bitstream/handle/document/92476/ssoar-2018-hanel-What_is_Rape_Social_Theory.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y&lnkname=ssoar-2018-hanel-What_is_Rape_Social_Theory.pdf

Joanne Conaghan, ‘The Essence of Rape’ (2014) 39(1) Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 151.

Jeannie A. Morris, ‘The Marital Rape Exemption Comment’ (1981) 27 Loyola Law Review 597.

Jan Pospisil et al, ‘Bring Enough Cows to Marry: Brideprice, Conflict and Gender Relations in South Sudan’ (2024) Peace and Conflict Resolution Evidence Platform.

Ibid, 21.

Ibid, 21.

Patricia Mahoney and Linda M. Williams, ‘Sexual Assault in Marriage: Prevalence, Consequences, and Treatment of Wife Rape’ (Brockbaker 1998) 113.

Fitzpatrick v Owen (1916) 186 S.W. 832

A. V. Dicey, ‘Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England’ (1932) 4(3) The Cambridge Law Journal 236.

R v Clarke [1949] 2 All ER 448

Judith A. Lincoln, ‘Abolishing the Marital Rape Exemption: The First Step in Protecting Married Woman from Spousal Rape’ (1988) 35 Wayne Law Review 1219.

Constitution of South Sudan Section 14

Siddeqqa Iram and Sambit Kumar Patri, ‘Is Marriage a Contract for Sexual Slavery?: A Study of Marital Rape’ (2023) NUALS Law Journal 17: 60.

Ibid, 18.

Barry Mitchell, ‘Multiple Wrongdoing and Offence Structure: A Plea for Consistency and Fair Labelling’ (2001) 64(3) The Modern Law Review 393.

James Chalmers and Fiona Leverick, ‘Fair Labelling in Criminal Law’ (2008) 71(2) Modern Law Review 217.

Andrew Cornford, ‘Beyond Fair Labelling: Offence Differentiation in Criminal Law’ (2022) 42(4) Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 985.

South Sudan Penal Code Section 255

Sarah M. Harless, ‘From the Bedroom to the Courtroom: The Impact of Domestic Violence Law on Marital Rape Victims’ (2003) 35 Rutgers Law Journal 305.

Three different forms of marital rape have been identified: (1) battered rape, which involves forced sex combined with beating; (2) forced rape, where the husband only uses as much force as necessary to coerce his wife into sexual activity; and (3) obsessive rape, which involves using force to carry out strange, perverse sexual interests.

Morgan Lee Woolley, ‘Marital Rape: A Unique Blend of Domestic Violence and Non-Marital Rape Issues’ (2007) 18 Hastings Women Law Journal 269.

Michelle Anderson, ‘Marital Immunity, Intimate Relationships, and Improper Inferences: A New Law on Sexual Offences by Intimates’ (2002) 54 Hastings Law Journal 1465.

Ibid, 33.

Ibid, 34.

Glanville Williams, ‘Convictions and Fair Labelling’ (1983) 42(1) The Cambridge Law Journal 85.

Moshikaro Khomotso, ‘The Moral Foundations of Fair Labelling’ (2024) Doctoral Dissertation viewed online at https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/items/7425dd23-acc7-4287-bd19-bf61608e60f5 on 15 May 2024.

South Sudan Penal Code Section 247(1)

South Sudan Penal Code Section 255(1)(c)

Ibid, 44.

Arlie Loughnan, ‘Women’s Responsibility for Crime: Dynamics of Change in Australia Since the Turn of the Twentieth Century’ (2018) 5(2) Law & History 137.

Jennifer McMahon-Howard et al, ‘Criminalizing Spousal Rape: The Diffusion of Legal Reforms’ (2009) 52(4) Sociological Perspectives 505.

Ibid, 39.

Mary Ellsberg et al, ‘No Safe Place: Prevalence and Correlates of Violence Against Conflict-affected Women and Girls in South Sudan’ (2020) 15(10) PLoS One e0237965.

Carolyne Gatimu, ‘Culture and Gender Based Violence in South Sudan’ (2018) Africa AMANI 112.

Medial Hove and Enock Ndawana, ‘Women’s Rights in Jeopardy: The Case of War-Torn South Sudan’ (2017) 7(4) Sage Open 2158244017737355.

Theresa Fus, ‘Criminalizing Marital Rape: A Comparison of Judicial and Legislative Approaches’ (2006) 39 Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law 481.

Ibid, 28.

International Covenant for Civil and Political Rights and International Covenant for Social, Cultural & Economic Rights; South Sudan has acceded to both treaties.

Tarehe ya Uchapishaji
20 Mei, 2025
Jinsi ya Kunukuu
Arop, N. (2025). South Sudan: Marital Rape Exemption. East African Journal of Law and Ethics, 8(1), 168-177. https://doi.org/10.37284/eajle.8.1.3021