Collaboration or Contravention? Ramifications For Effective Participatory Decision-Making in Collaborative Forest Management at Echuya Central Forest Reserve, South Western Uganda
Abstract
Participatory decision-making has been extensively adopted worldwide as an essential mechanism and a good governance principle to reach a consensus in natural resource management. However, in most communities, local people who depend on forests are not involved in the decision-making process regarding conserving protected areas. This research assesses the ramifications of collaboration or contravention on effective participatory decision-making in collaborative forest management in Echuya Central Forest Reserve. It provides insights into how community consultations and participation of forest-adjacent communities in planning meetings influence the conservation of protected areas. We collected data from a total of 639 respondents, including Collaborative Forest Management (CFM) group members and non-CFM community members, government institutions, conservation organizations, and local community leaders, using semi-structured questionnaires, interview guides, and Focus Group Discussion guides. Results indicate that community consultations allow CFM stakeholders, particularly community members, to give ideas on how such projects can be implemented without destroying forest resources, promoting the goal of conserving the forest reserve. Community members’ participation in planning meetings allows them to contribute ideas about relevant and appropriate forest conservation approaches. However, the National Forestry Authority (NFA) and other non-community actor groups dominate the decision-making process mainly because the NFA has the legal mandate to manage the forest reserve on behalf of the Government. We concluded that the connivance of government forestry officials with unauthorized forest resource users undermines the spirit of participatory decision-making. Dishonesty and lack of accountability hampered effective participatory decision-making, and low attendance at meetings undermines effective participation in decision-making. Thus, community members’ consistent attendance of meetings is paramount for positive outcomes of participatory decision-making for the conservation of forests
Downloads
References
Anguti, S., Mukadasi, B. & Andama, E. (2022). Cost- Benefit Analysis of Collaborative Forest Management: A Case Study of Tororo Central Forest Reserve, Eastern Uganda East African Journal of Forestry and Agroforestry, 5(1), 76- 95. https://doi.org/10.37284/eajfa.5.1.745
Baker, G., Davies, C, Evans, J., Goodstadt, V., Hodge, S., Howell, B., Rowe, G. & Sangster, M. (2016). Involving communities in forestry. The Forestry Authority Commission, Britain.
Bitariho, R., Babaasa, D., & Mugerwa, B. (2015). The Status of Biodiversity in Echuya Central Forest Reserve, SW Uganda. Institute of Tropical Forest Conservation, Mbarara University of Science and Technology
Bitariho, R. & McNeilage (2004). Sustainable harvest of Bamboo in Echuya Central Forest Reserve, S. W Uganda, unpublished report of Institute of Tropical Forest Conservation, Ruhija, Kabale.
Bruna-Garcia, X., & MArey-Pérez, M. F. (2014). Public participation: a need of forest planning. I Forest-Biogeosciences and Forestry, 7(4), 216.
Buncag, M. J. J. (2021). Community-based mangrove forest management sustainability: The case of some Asian countries. International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR), 10(4), 918-26.
Byaruhanga A, Kasoma P & Pomeroy D (2001). Important Bird Areas in Uganda. East Africa
Natural History Society, Kampala
Charlene, K. J., Nortey, D. D., Amoakoh, A. O., & Assumadu, R. (2017). Community Participation in Forest Management in the Bleih Community Forest, Nimba County, Liberia. North Asian International Research Journal of Multidisciplinary ISSN: 2454 - 2326 Vol. 3, Issue 1, Jan.
Dobrynin, D., Smirennikova, E., & Mustalahti, I. (2020). Non-state forest governance and ‘Responsibilization’: The prospects for FPIC under FSC certification in Northwest Russia. Forest Policy and Economics, 115, 102142.
Foncha, J. N., & Ewule, D. M. (2020). Community Forest Management: A Strategy for Rehabilitation, Conservation and Livelihood Sustainability: The Case of Mount Oku, Cameroon. Journal of Geoscience and Environment Protection, 8(02), 1.
Gbetnkom, D. (2009). Forest Depletion and Food Security of Poor Rural Populations in Africa: Evidence from Cameroon. Journal of African Economies, Volume 18, Issue 2, 1 March, Pages 261–286
Goldberg, L., Lagomasino, D., Thomas, N., & Fatoyinbo, T. (2020). Global declines in human‐driven mangrove loss. Global change biology, 26(10), 5844-5855.
Goldman, E., Weisse, M., Harris, N., & Schneider, M. (2020). Estimating the role of seven commodities in agriculture-linked deforestation: Oil palm, soy, cattle, wood fiber, cocoa, coffee, and rubber. Technical Note, World Resources Institute.
GoU (Government of Uganda). (2001). The Uganda Forestry Policy, 2001. Government of Uganda publication.
GoU (Government of Uganda). (2003). The National Forestry and Tree Planting Act, 2003. Government of Uganda publication.
Hughes, A., Shen, X., Corlett, R., Li, L., Luo, M., Woodley, S., ... & Ma, K. (2022). Challenges and possible solutions to creating an achievable and effective Post-2020 Global Biodiversity Framework. Ecosystem Health and Sustainability, 8(1), 2124196.
Jung, M., Alagador, D., Chapman, M., Hermoso, V., Kujala, H., O’Connor, L., ... & Visconti, P. (2024). An assessment of the state of conservation planning in Europe. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 379(1902), 20230015.
Katwinomugisha, R., & Katebaka, R. (2017). Reflections and recommendations from the collaborative forest management national dialogue. A dialogue report by African union of conservationists (AUC) Kampala, Uganda.
Kazoora, C., Irumba, D., Smithand, N & Campese, J (2020). A review of Collaborative Forest Management in Uganda. Overview. Ministry of Water and Environment, Uganda
Kegamba, J. J., Sangha, K. K., Wurm, P., & Garnett, S. T. (2022). A review of conservation-related benefit-sharing mechanisms in Tanzania. Global Ecology and Conservation, 33, e01955.
Lise, J. (2009). Integrated environmental management; the foundation for successful practice. Environmental management, 24(2), 152-154
Luswaga, H., & Nuppenau, E. A. (2020). Participatory forest management in West Usambara Tanzania: What is the community perception on success? Sustainability 12(3): 921.
Mawa, C., Babweteera, F., Tabuti, J. R. S., & Tumusiime, D. M. (2020). Changes in vegetation characteristics following a decade of community forest management in mid-western Uganda. International Forestry Review, 22(3), 323-338.
Nabanyumya, R., Mugyenyi, O., Naluwairo, R., & Amumpiire, A. (2017). Benefit Sharing In The Forestry Sector in Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania: Status, Lessons and Recommendations for Uganda. ACODE Policy Briefing Paper Series, No. 46, 2017, Kampala
N’tambwe Nghonda, D. D., Muteya, H. K., Kashiki, B. K. W. N., Sambiéni, K. R., Malaisse, F., Sikuzani, Y. U., ... & Bogaert, J. (2023). Towards an inclusive approach to forest management: highlight of the perception and participation of local communities in the management of miombo woodlands around Lubumbashi (Haut-Katanga, DR Congo). Forests, 14(4), 687.
NFA [National Forestry Authority] (2007). Community Forest Management Arrangement Agreement. Kabale, Uganda.
NFA [National Forestry Authority] (2003). Guidelines for implementing Collaborative Forest Management in Uganda, Republic of Uganda, Kampala
NFA [National Forestry Authority] (2007). Community Forest Management Arrangement Agreement. Kabale, Uganda.
Oladeji, S. O., Grace, O., & Ayodeji, A. A. (2022). Community Participation in Conservation and Management of Cultural Heritage Resources in Yoruba Ethnic Group of South Western Nigeria. SAGE Open, 12(4), 21582440221130987.
Ordóñez, C., Kendal, D., Threlfall, C. G., Hochuli, D. F., Davern, M., Fuller, R. A., & Livesley, S. J. (2020). How urban forest managers evaluate management and governance challenges in their decision-making. Forests, 11(9), 963.
Park, S. H., & Yeo-Chang, Y. (2021). Impact of collaborative forest management on rural
livelihood: A case study of maple sap collecting households in South Korea. Sustainability, 13(4), 1594.
Pham, T. T., Castella, J. C., Lestrelin, G., Mertz, O., Le, D. N., Moeliono, M., & Nguyen, T. D. (2015). Adapting free, prior, and informed consent (FPIC) to local contexts in REDD+: Lessons from three experiments in Vietnam. Forests, 6(7), 2405-2423.
Plumptre, A.J., Behangana, M., Davenport, T.R.B., Kahindo, C., Kityo, R., Ndomba, E.,
Nkuutu, D., Owiunji, I., Ssegawa, P., Eilu, G., 2003. The Biodiversity of the Albertine Rift. Albertine Rift Technical Reports No. 3, p. 105. Available from: http:
Prouty, C.; Koenig, E.S.; Wells, E.C.; Zarger, R.K., & Zhang, Q. (2017). Rapid assessment framework for modelling stakeholder involvement in infrastructure development. Sustain. Cities Soc., 29, 130–138.
Rhodes, J. R., Guerrero, A. M., Bodin, Ö., & Chadès, I. (2020). Fundamental insights on when social network data are most critical for conservation planning. Conservation Biology, 34(6), 1463-1472.
Roberts, P., Hamilton, R., & Piperno, D. R. (2021). Tropical forests as key sites of the “Anthropocene”: Past and present perspectives. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(40), e2109243118.
Ssali, F., & Bitariho, R. (2013). Status and Distribution of Montane Bamboo in Echuya
Central Forest Reserve, S.W. Uganda. Institute of Tropical Forest Conservation, Ruhija, Kabale, Uganda
Silver, C., & Lewins, A. (2014). Using Software in Qualitative Research. A step-by-Step Guide. Second Edition. Sage Publication.
Soliev, I., Theesfeld, I., Abert, E., & Schramm, W. (2021). Benefit sharing and conflict transformation: Insights for and from REDD+ forest governance in sub-Saharan Africa. Forest Policy and Economics, 133, 102623.
Somuah, D. P., Ros–Tonen, M. A., & Baud, I. S. A. (2021). Local spatialized knowledge of threats to forest conservation in Ghana’s high forest zone. Environmental management, 68(5), 738-754.
Tindan, P. D. (2013). The causes of and impact from deforestation on local level sustainable forest management in Ghana. A survey of Dwease and Draaso communities in the Ashanti Region. The University of Agder, Kristiansand S, Norway.
Trigueiro, W. R., Nabout, J. C., & Tessarolo, G. (2020). Uncovering the spatial variability of recent deforestation drivers in the Brazilian Cerrado. Journal of Environmental Management, 275, 111243.
Twinamatsiko, M., Rugunda, G.K., Basheka, B., & De Herdt, T. (2015). Can Governance in Revenue Sharing Be a Pathway for a Win-win Situation between People’s Livelihood Improvement and Conservation? Journal of Social Science Research Vol .8, No.1
UNCED. (1992). Earth Summit-Rio Declaration and forest principles. United Nations, Department of Public Information, USA.
Wily, L. A. (1998). Villagers as forest managers and governments “learning to let go”. The case of DuruHaitemba and Mgori Forests in Tanzania. Forest Participation Series, No 9. International Institute for Environment and Development, London, UK.
Zhang, Y., Xiao, X., Cao, R., Zheng, C., Guo, Y., Gong, W., & Wei, Z. (2020). How important is community participation to eco-environmental conservation in protected areas? From the perspective of predicting locals’ pro- environmental behaviours. Science of the Total Environment, 739, 139889
Copyright (c) 2024 Medard Twinamatsiko, PhD, Stephen Gumisiriza Bugabo
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
